"You gave me socks?" Rey asked in shock as she held the two fluffy pieces of fabric in the air. "Everyone needs socks," Elijah defended himself and I felt Cas laugh next to me.

"You're not good at giving gifts!"

Reyna tried to suppress the grin as she leaned over and hugged Elijah. "Don't listen to him. I think she's great."

Elijah pouted.

"You're only saying that because you don't want to hurt my feelings."

"You have feelings?" Cas asked, laughing. A pillow hit him in the face and now I was the one laughing.

We sat together in the living room, on the floor, with our backs against the...