Bill was first to arrive home. He jumped in the shower to rinse off from his day and once he had changed into a pair of shorts and a T-shirt, he ordered Chinese food for both he and Rachel. As he waited for both his roommate and their food, he strategically placed the pedicure gift card on the kitchen counter. He would go with the story that he won a raffle that he never remembered entering at work. There's no reason he could think of that Rachel wouldn't believe it.

Rachel came home about fifteen minutes later than usual. She strolled through the tiled kitchen in her heels to get...