“I was the daughter that vanished in the neighborhood four years ago.”

            “You mean…” I tried to calm myself but my heart didn’t listen. “You were the daughter of the family that previously lived in our house?”

            Melissa nodded. My soon-to-be sister-in-law was the former one who lived in our house.

            “Is this entire thing a coincidence? You, being my sister-in-law who was the daughter of the previous occupants of the house we just moved in. Tyler being the ‘Jordan’ I met last year who I had a one night with—”

            “Wait,” Melissa and Rowena’s eyes turned to me. “You and Tyler already did it?”

            Oh boy. Oh. Boy.

            “Uhm,...