Elizabeth was startled when she heard Charles' voice.

What was he doing here? That's the question that was inside her mind

She didn't expect that he was here and he even had the courage to ask if he could join them for dinner.

But before she could even respond to him, Arnold already did.

"Yes, please come join us," Arnold said and then he stood up to get a plate and cutlery for Charles who was already sitting next to her.

If she would be asked, she didn't want to eat with the man but Arnold was just kind.

She couldn't believe that Arnold could still let the man in...