“Paul had told me, ‘Every time the guy moved or moaned, I kicked him,’ and I was afraid he might really have been hurt bad.

“The next day, Cindy went down by the lake and came back and said, ‘They’re taking some young girl’s body out of the lake. She’s been raped and murdered.’ When I told this to Paul, he seemed nervous and sick.”

In the meantime, Cindy Mateska was telling Detective Harrison an identical version of Paul Vinetti’s homecoming on Saturday night. “Paul came in with his sleeves rolled up and blood all over his hands and arms. He knows I disapprove of drinking and I scolded him...