"I was just getting to that. If you want $2,000, you'll have to let him fuck your ass. How does that sound?"

I took a deep breath. Several boyfriends had tried anal with me before and I wasn't fond of it but for another $500, I figured I might as well do it as long as I'd be going this far so I replied, "Yeah, I'll do anal."

"That's great. The subscribers love anal. It's even better if you say you've never done it before."

"Okay."

He made me sign a bunch of release forms and provide two forms of ID to verify I was of legal age. He told...