I wasn't sure about this but I was hot, drunk, and desperately wanted to please Sarah so I let her continue. I felt a coldness on my asshole then a little pressure before she slid the butt plug slowly into my ass. When it was fully inserted, Sarah wiped the extra lube away with some tissue and slapped my ass to let me know she was done.

"Aren't you going to take it out?"

Sarah laughed and replied, "Oh no my dear, it's staying in there for the rest of the evening."

I was thinking, "You've got to be shitting me," but I trusted Sarah and stood up.

It felt...