"Mmmm, James, Edgar has wanted to fuck you ever since I introduced you guys." Taylor was talking to me as he slowly pulled out and thrust in. I grinded with her confessions.

"I remember that night in bed. I made Edgar cum by talking about how hot it would be for us to spread your ass and show you a hard cock for the first time."

I couldn't believe what Taylor was saying to me.

"Yep, I came hard that night," Edgar chimed in, even as he firmly filled me, over and over again. "I remember you said you didn't think we'd ever be able to convince him to try...