After I got out and dried off, I put lotion all over to soothe my skin. We planned to trim and paint our nails while we watched a movie later, so I just scraped off the last of my glittery polish before getting dressed.

My favorite boyshort panties and lacy bra went on first so we could have fun taking them off. Next came soft blue shorts and a pink tee that stopped right under my belly button. I put my damp hair back in a tail as I went down the hallway and stopped dead at the stairs.

“But I’m not a virgin,” I heard Bethany giggle as she...